XOM vs VLO

	XOM ExxonMobil Holdings Corp	VLO Valero Energy Corp
Price	$178.23	$426.28
Sector	Energy	Energy
X-Ray Score	42	41
Valuation	21	39
Growth	34	11
Profitability	52	50
Financial health	60	69
Dividends	56	28
Fair value	$169	$430
Verdict	Fair -5%	Fair +1%
Revenue (TTM)	$368.8B	$139.4B
Operating margin	12.5%	7.2%
Return on capital	11.8%	27.2%
Revenue growth (3y)	-7.0%	-11.4%
Free-cash-flow yield	4.1%	–
Net debt / EBITDA	0.4×	0.3×
Dividend yield	2.3%	1.1%

Scores and fair values are model estimates from SEC filings, ranked within each company's own sector, so scores of companies in different sectors are not directly comparable. Educational only, not financial advice.